Appeal the decision of the court of cassation

Appeal the decision of the court of cassation

The decision of the court of cassation is a final decision, it is not subject to appeal. However, this does not mean that it cannot be challenged. There are certain exceptions that allow review of the decision of the highest court. We will look at this in more detail below. Experts of the legal company “Prikhodko and Partners” will always help in complex legal cases.

Grounds for appeal

Significant violations of legal norms:

  • Incorrect interpretation or application of legal norms:
  1. Incorrect determination by the court of the legal nature of the disputed legal relationship;
  2. Application by the court of a non-existent or canceled rule of law;
  3. Non-application by the court of the rule of law that was subject to application;
  4. Incorrect interpretation of the content of legal norms by the court.
  • Failure of the court of cassation to investigate all the circumstances of the case:
  1. Improper verification of evidence by the court;
  2. Underestimation or overestimation of evidence by the court;
  3. Failure of the court to clarify all the circumstances relevant to the case.
  • Improper evaluation of evidence by the court of cassation instance:
  1. Violation of the rules of evaluation of evidence by the court;
  2. Unfounded conclusion of the court about the reliability or unreliability of the evidence;
  3. Failure of the court to take into account all the circumstances that are important for the evaluation of the evidence.
  • Making a decision that does not correspond to the factual circumstances of the case established by the court:
  1. Incorrect determination of the factual circumstances of the case by the court;
  2. Failure to clarify the cause-and-effect relationship between the facts by the court;
  3. Inconsistency of the court’s conclusions with the actual circumstances of the case.

Discovery of new circumstances:

  • New evidence that could not be submitted to the court earlier:
  1. Evidence that became known after the court decision was rendered;
  2. Evidence that could not be submitted to the court for valid reasons.
  • Falsification of the evidence on which the court decision is based:
  1. Forgery of documents;
  2. Submission of knowingly false testimony to the court;
  3. Other ways of falsifying evidence.
  • Illegal obtaining of evidence:
  1. Obtaining evidence in violation of the norms of procedural law;
  2. Use of evidence obtained illegally.

Other grounds:

  • Violation of the right to access to justice:
  1. A person’s inability to participate in the proceedings;
  2. Failure to provide the person with the opportunity to present his arguments and evidence;
  3. Unreasonable failure of the court to consider the application.
  • Violation of the right to a fair trial:
  1. Bias of judges;
  2. The impartiality of the trial;
  3. Unreasonable diversion of requests of a person.

Important points

  • The list of grounds for appealing the decision of the court of cassation is exhaustive.
  • The decision of the court of cassation can be appealed only if one of the above grounds is present.
  • The grounds for appealing the decision of the cassation court must be clearly and substantiated in the extraordinary cassation appeal.
  • The extraordinary cassation appeal must be accompanied by evidence confirming the existence of grounds for appeal.

Appealing the decision of the court of cassation: why you need the help of lawyers

Appealing the decision of the court of cassation is an extremely complex and time-consuming process that requires deep knowledge of jurisprudence, experience in working with cassation appeals and understanding of the nuances of the judicial process. It is almost impossible to challenge such a decision on your own and have a chance of success.

  • High level of difficulty:

The process of appealing the decision of the court of cassation is regulated by procedural codes, which contain many strict requirements for the form and content of the complaint, deadlines for its submission, attached evidence, etc. Ignorance of these requirements or their violation may lead to the rejection of the complaint.

  • Specifics of the cassation appeal:

The cassation instance does not check the legality and reasonableness of court decisions on the merits, but only investigates whether the courts of previous instances committed violations of the law. Therefore, for a successful appeal, it is necessary to clearly formulate and justify exactly the violation of legal norms that affected the correctness of the decision.

  • Need for experience and knowledge:

Preparing and submitting an extraordinary cassation appeal requires knowledge and understanding of the practice of the Supreme Court of Ukraine, case law, as well as the ability to correctly interpret and apply legal norms.

Legal assistance

Our lawyers, who have experience with cassation appeals, will be able to:

  • Analyze the court decision and determine whether there are really grounds for appealing it;
  • Formulate and substantiate grounds for appeal;
  • Prepare an extraordinary cassation appeal in accordance with the requirements of the procedural law;
  • Collect and add the necessary evidence to the complaint;
  • Represent your interests in court.

Contacting lawyers significantly increases the chances of successfully challenging the decision of the court of cassation.

For consultation or calculation of the price of appeal of the decision of the court of cassation – fill out the form below.

Calculate the cost of services

1 question

Have other lawyers handled your case?

Yes
No

2 question

Are you in Kyiv or Kyiv region?

Yes
No

3 question

Do you need legal assistance urgently?

Yes
No

You may also need:

20%
discount
If we do not
call back
during the day
Consultation
Law company
Leave a request for legal assistance right now:
9+ years on the market
70+ professional practitioners
Fixed price
Online / offline consultation

Lawyer services

A lawyer during the search of an apartment/private house A lawyer for questioning a suspect/witness/victim – the price of accompanying a lawyer for questioning A lawyer in a business process A lawyer on economic issues in Europe A lawyer under Article 286 of the Criminal Code. Violation of the rules of road traffic safety or operation of transport by persons driving vehicles A statement of claim for the recognition of the right of ownership Accident lawyer Accompanying a disabled person across the border Accompanying a lawyer at the border when crossing the border legally Administrative lawsuit to challenge the decision/actions/inaction of the subject of authority Admission of guilt in criminal proceedings Adoption lawyer Advertising lawyer Alimony lawyer Anti-rading measures Appeal against decision to discontinue criminal proceedings Appeal against illegal detention Appeal against the commencement decision Appeal against the decision of the court of appeal in cassation Appeal against the decision to change the preventive measure Appeal against the decision to elect a preventive measure Appeal against the refusal to open criminal proceedings Appeal against the ruling of the investigating judge Appeal of NSDC sanctions Appeal of personal sanctions Appeal of sanctions imposed on a natural or legal entity Appeal of the court decision under Art. 130 of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses Appeal the decision of the arbitration court Appeal the decision of the court of appeal Appeal the decision of the court of cassation Appeal the decision of the court of first instance Appealing a court verdict in a criminal case Appealing the actions of a private executor Appealing the decision on seizure of property Appealing the decision on the selection of the event Appealing the refusal to cross the border Attorney (international lawyer) in Argentina Attorney (international lawyer) in Indonesia Attorney (International Lawyer) in Paraguay ATTORNEY FOR VIP CLIENTS Attorney in Odessa Auto inspection lawyer Business Audit Lawyer Business reputation lawyer Business support lawyer Cancellation of the fine under Article 164 Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses CAR ATTORNEY FROM ST. 130 of the CODE OF UKRAINE ON ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENSES Car customs clearance lawyer Car driver protection Car rental lawyer Cassation appeal in a criminal case Challenging the actions of the Security Intelligence Service, Security Service, Police Challenging the court’s decision in the appeal procedure Challenging the illegal detention of a person: your rights and options Change of purpose of the land plot Changing the preventive measure during the pre-trial investigation Civil lawyer Closure of criminal proceedings Collectors lawyer Compensation for damage caused by a road accident COMPENSATION OF DAMAGES CAUSED BY ILLEGAL ACTIONS BY STATE AUTHORITIES Computer Crime Lawyer – Cybercrime Lawyer Construction disputes lawyer Consultation of a lawyer on crossing the border of Ukraine Consultation of a lawyer regarding border crossing under martial law Consultation with a lawyer on medical law Consumer Protection Lawyer Contract lawyer Copyright lawyer Corporate attorney in Ukraine Corruption lawyer Counterfeit lawyer Crime lawyer Criminal liability for humiliation of honor and dignity Crossing the border on the basis of accompanying a disabled person Crossing the border with a disabled person Cryptocurrency / cryptowallet fraud Customs lawyer DAMAGES AND COLLECTION OF PENALTY Debt collection from a legal entity or individual entrepreneurship (feo) Debt lawyer (debt collection) Defendant at criminal justice – help of a lawyer at criminal justice Defense of the lawyer at the pre-trial investigation Defense of the lawyer at the preliminary investigation Departure of the lawyer for detention in the city of Kyiv Departure of the lawyer for the raider seizure Deprivation of parental rights lawyer Disability lawyer DISOBEDIENCE, WILLFULLY LEAVING A MILITARY UNIT OR PLACE OF SERVICE Division / consolidation of land DIVORCE LAWYER Documents for traveling abroad for disabled people of group 2 Drug lawyer ECHR lawyer ECONOMIC CRIME LAWYER Estate Litigation Attorney Execution of court decision Execution of court decisions on imovable property and land plots Extradition lawyer Failure to fulfill contractual obligations by legal entities File an appeal against a court decision in a criminal case – the price of filing an appeal File an appeal against the court’s decision Filing a cassation appeal Filing an application under the ECHR Fraud lawyer Fraud Lawyer Services Get a certificate (excerpt) about your criminal record Get an extract from the Unified Register of Pretrial Investigations Hooliganism lawyer House Noise Lawyer Housing lawyer How to appeal a court decision? Immigration attorney Insurance lawyer Intellectual Property Lawyer International affairs attorney International attorney (international lawyer) in Ecuador International criminal lawyer Internet Fraud (Article 190 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine) Interpol international search Investment lawyer: support of investment projects and disputes Land grabbing lawyer Land registration lawyer Lawyer (International Attorney) in Canada Lawyer (international attorney) in Venezuela Lawyer (international lawyer) in Australia Lawyer (international lawyer) in Brazil Lawyer (international lawyer) in Cuba Lawyer (international lawyer) in Mexico Lawyer abroad. International lawyer Lawyer at the European Court of Human Rights Lawyer consultation Lawyer during interrogation Lawyer for credit debts Lawyer for criminal conspiracy (407 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine) – what is criminal conspiracy and how to avoid punishment for criminal conspiracy in wartime? Lawyer for criminal rights Lawyer for land registration matters Lawyer for property disputes Lawyer for violation of customs regulations Lawyer for violent crimes – Lawyer under Article 153 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine (sexual violence) Lawyer from abroad Lawyer in Africa Lawyer in Austria Lawyer in Bulgaria Lawyer in China Lawyer in court Lawyer in criminal cases (proceedings) in Italy Lawyer in criminal cases during a traffic accident Lawyer in criminal cases in Poland Lawyer in criminal proceedings Lawyer in Dominican Republic Lawyer in Egypt Lawyer in Estonia Lawyer in Europe (EU) Lawyer in Finland Lawyer in France Lawyer in Germany Lawyer in Greece Lawyer in Italy Lawyer in Latvia Lawyer in Lithuania Lawyer in Moldova Lawyer in Netherlands (Holland) Lawyer in Norway Lawyer in Oman Lawyer in Poland Lawyer in Romania Lawyer in Saudi Arabia Lawyer in Slovakia Lawyer in South Africa Lawyer in Sweden Lawyer in Switzerland Lawyer in the case of fraud with financial resources Lawyer in the UAE Lawyer in the USA Lawyer in Turkey Lawyer on bribes Lawyer on economic affairs Lawyer on international law (lawyer on international affairs) Lawyer services in Kyiv Lawyer under Art. 200 of the Criminal Code – Illegal actions with transfer documents, payment cards and other means of access to bank accounts, electronic money Lawyer under Art. 203-2 of the Criminal Code – Illegal activity of organizing or conducting gambling games, lotteries Lawyer under Article 124 of the KUpAP Lawyer under Article 185 of the Criminal Code — Theft Lawyer under Article 212 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine Lawyer under Article 302 of the Criminal Code – Creation or maintenance of places of debauchery and solicitation Lawyer under Article 303 of the Criminal Code – Pimping or engaging a person in prostitution Lawyer under Article 369-2 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine – Abuse of influence Lawyer under Article 411 of the Criminal Code – Intentional destruction or damage to military property Legal defense in a criminal case Legal support for agricultural enterprises when purchasing land at auctions Legal support for citizens of Ukraine when crossing the border legally Loan attorney Medical Lawyer – Kyiv Medical Lawyer in Dnipro Medical Lawyer in Lviv: Legal Support and Protection of Rights Medical Lawyer in Odesa Medical Lawyer Kharkiv Military criminal lawyer Obtaining town-planning conditions and restrictions on building OFFENSIVENESS OF GOVERNMENT REGISTERS AND SUBJECTS OF GOVERNMENT REGISTRATIONS ONLINE REPUTATION MANAGEMENT Payment of insurance compensation in the event of a road accident Pension lawyer Petition to close criminal proceedings PPR lawyer Preparation for search Problem car lawyer Property Crimes Lawyer PROPERTY DIVISION LAWYER Protection of consumer rights Protection of consumer rights: return of goods Protection of honor and dignity and business reputation Protection of human rights in the ECtHR Protection of interests in criminal proceedings Protection of the business reputation of a legal entity Protection of the guarantor’s interests in court Quarantine Lawyer Raiding lawyer Real estate lawyer RECOGNITION OF BUSINESS AGREEMENTS VOID Recognition of property ownership in court Recovery of damages from the culprit of the road accident Recovery of funds from the culprit of the road accident Removal of arrest from a car in criminal proceedings Removal of seizure from property after closing of criminal proceedings Representation in criminal proceedings Representation in the housing office or OSBB Representation of the interests of the victim in criminal proceedings Responsibility for humiliation of honor and dignity Restitution of rights after their deprivation Restoring a driver’s license abroad Return of driver’s license after an accident Return of driver’s license after Article 130 of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses Road accident with victims, Article 286 of the Code of Criminal Procedure – a lawyer for a road accident with a victim Road attorney Salary account unlocking Search for captured / missing soldiers Search for missing servicemen Search of the apartment – consultation and calling of a lawyer during the search of the apartment SES lawyer State registration of land rental Statement of claim for cancellation of debt for utility services Stolen car search lawyer Submission of an application to the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) Submission of the NAZK declaration – support for the submission of the declaration Tax audit assistance TAX CRIMES LAWYER Technical documentation (project) TERMINATION OF BUSINESS CONTRACTS Termination of suretyship in court The return of property of a legal entity The term of appeal of the decision of the investigating judge Theft lawyer Urgent call of a lawyer: your protection in the most difficult situations Urgent departure of a lawyer to the place of investigation or seizure in Kyiv Urgent departure of the lawyer during the search Urgent summons of a lawyer for a search Utility bills lawyer VAT lawyer What to do when the apartment is flooded? Withdrawal from the international wanted list of Interpol Worker Protection Lawyer