Attorney
Lawyer, expert in tax law, protection of clients' interests in tax disputes, provision of professional advice on tax issues, appeal of unlawful decisions of tax authorities, optimization of tax burden.
Tax claim appeal
Appealing the decision of controlling bodies is an important legal process that many individuals and entrepreneurs in Ukraine face. A demand from the controlling body may be issued if the body believes that the subject of taxation has not paid taxes in full or has violated tax legislation. Regardless of the grounds on which such a claim was made, every person has the right to appeal this decision in a legal manner.
General aspects of the appeal
First of all, the appeal of the requirements of the controlling body begins with a thorough analysis of the document received from the relevant body. This can be a request, notification-decision, or inspection report. It is important to pay attention to what specific violations are specified, what legal norms the controlling body relies on, and what amount of tax obligations is determined to be paid. The appeal strategy will depend on these aspects.
One of the most important aspects for an appeal is compliance with the deadlines for filing a complaint. According to the Tax Code of Ukraine, the taxpayer has the right to file a complaint within 10 calendar days from the moment of receiving a tax notification-decision or demand. If this deadline is missed, the decision of the controlling body will be considered accepted and an appeal is possible only in court. Therefore, it is important not to delay filing a complaint and act promptly.
Reasons for appealing a tax decision
The main grounds for appealing the decision of the supervisory body may be the following:
- Improper application of tax legislation. Controlling bodies can interpret tax rules incorrectly, which leads to incorrect accruals of tax liabilities. For example, the authority may incorrectly interpret the definition of economic operation or make a mistake in the qualification of certain income or expenses.
- Procedural violations during inspection. Tax audits must be conducted in compliance with all established procedures. If the inspection was carried out with violations, for example, procedural errors were made, there is no proper justification of the accrued tax liabilities, or the inspection was carried out outside the specified time limits, this may be grounds for cancellation of the claim.
- Incorrect calculation of tax obligations. Controlling bodies often make mistakes in calculations. This may be due to incorrect data, accounting errors or inaccuracies in the calculations provided by the taxpayers themselves. If the calculation of tax amounts does not correspond to the actual data provided by the taxpayer, this is grounds for appeal.
- Absence of supporting documents from the controlling body. The body must provide all the necessary evidence to support its conclusions. If the controlling body cannot provide such evidence or the evidence provided is questionable, this may also be grounds for cancellation of the requirement.
- No fault of the payer. If the taxpayer proves that the tax violation was caused by objective reasons, for example due to force majeure or errors caused by extraneous factors, the requirements of the controlling body may be removed.
How to appeal a tax claim?
If during the analysis you came to the conclusion that the demand is unreasonable, the first step is to prepare a justified written complaint. In this complaint, you should clearly indicate which aspects of the decision you do not agree with, provide all the necessary evidence to support your position, and refer to the relevant legal provisions violated by the controlling body.
The text of the complaint should also indicate possible procedural violations on the part of the controlling body, if any. For example, it may be a violation of the terms of the inspection or non-compliance by the inspectors with the requirements for drawing up inspection reports. Procedural violations are often one of the most common grounds for revoking the decisions of regulatory bodies.
In addition, when appealing, it is also important to pay attention to the legality of the body’s actions from the point of view of legislation. According to the Constitution of Ukraine, controlling bodies are obliged to act exclusively on the basis, within the limits of their powers and in the manner prescribed by law. If the request does not meet the requirements of the legislation or goes beyond the powers of the controlling body, it can be considered illegal.
If the supervisory body does not satisfy your complaint, the next step may be to file a claim with the administrative court. The procedure for judicial appeal of tax decisions is regulated by the Code of Administrative Proceedings of Ukraine. In the case of a judicial appeal against a tax decision, it is important to have all the documents confirming your position in hand, including copies of appeals, body responses and other evidence.
However, it is important to remember that in most cases claims can be successfully appealed already at the pre-trial stage. Controlling authorities are interested in settling disputes with taxpayers within the framework of the administrative process, as this reduces the burden on the judicial system and avoids unnecessary costs.
In conclusion, appealing the requirements of regulatory bodies is a process that requires attentiveness, responsibility and a thorough approach. If you are sure that the demand is unreasonable, you should not be afraid to defend your rights. Appealing the decision of the controlling body is a legal right of every taxpayer, and in many cases this process ends in favor of the taxable entity.
Calculate the cost of services
1 question
Did other lawyers deal with your case?
2 question
Are you in Kyiv or Kyiv region?
3 question
Have you already received a tax claim?
4 question
Do you need the advice of a tax lawyer?
Is it possible to get a lawyer's consultation online if it is not possible to come to the office?
Of course. We provide consultations both online and in the office. Online consultation is possible in any convenient way for the client. It can be a video call through a convenient messenger or a video conference format.
Where to complain to the tax office?
You can appeal the decision of the tax office in the district administrative court. We provide full support for tax disputes. If you need legal support that will give results – leave a request on our website.
call back
during the day
Compensation for moral, material damage
Protection of honour, dignity, and business reputationContract Development for Business and Legal Entities
Licensing of business activities
Compensation for moral, material damage
Legal services in the field of cryptocurrency and blockchain
REGISTRATION OF COMPANIES AND OPENING OF BANK ACCOUNTS
Sale and purchase of ready-made firms
Grants and attracting investment
Business registration and support in Great Britain
Business registration and support in Switzerland
Business registration and support in the EU
Business Registration and Support in the Gulf Countries (GCC)
Business registration and support in Turkey
Business registration and support in USA
Lawyer for administrative cases
Legal services for medical businesses and doctors
Protection of honour, dignity, and business reputation
Real estate transaction support
Escort of the tender participant
Trial lawyer: support and defense in court
European Court of Human Rights (ECHR)



