Lawyer, mediator, specializing in real estate, corporate, financial, tax, civil and contract law, as well as litigation.
Appeal against a court decision in a civil case
Participants in a civil dispute have the right to file an appeal and challenge the decision of the court of first instance. The plaintiff, the defendant, third parties, or even those who did not participate in the case but whose interests are affected by the court decision, can prepare an appeal and file it within the time limit specified in the current Civil Procedure Code. Such a legal mechanism exists primarily to correct judicial errors and achieve the most favorable outcome for the party to the dispute. In more detail about how to prepare an appeal and how our specialists can help, we will consider in the article below.
When is an appeal filed?
Appeals are heard by the courts of the district where the local court that issued the first decision is located. Two types of judicial acts can be appealed – decisions (on the basis of their non-compliance with the legislation), rulings (on individual issues). The law distinguishes two categories of rulings that can be appealed, in particular:
- resolutions that are appealed separately from the court decision (refusal to open proceedings, return of the statement of claim, leaving the claim without consideration, closing the proceedings, ordering an examination, etc.);
- resolutions that are appealed together with the decision of the court of first instance (request for evidence, satisfaction of the petition, etc.).
What is the deadline for filing an appeal against a court decision in a civil case?
The law clearly distinguishes the deadlines depending on the type of judicial act. Thus, according to the current Civil Procedure Code, a decision can be appealed within 30 days from the date of its announcement, and a ruling – within 15 days. If only the introductory and operative parts were read out in court, then the deadline is calculated from the date of the full text of the decision and its publication, respectively.
How to properly prepare an appeal?
A formal error when preparing an appeal can lead to the document being returned by the court without further consideration. Therefore, it is important to take into account the provisions of Articles 355 and 356 of the Civil Procedure Code, according to which an appeal must be drawn up in writing and must contain the following blocks:
- details – name of the appellate court, details of the complainant and other participants, means of communication;
- descriptive part – the decision being appealed, date of receipt;
- motivational part – explanation of the error of the court of first instance, reference to the provisions of the law, description of new evidence in the case (if any);
- requirements in the complaint – request to the court (to cancel the previous decision, adopt a new one, make changes, etc.);
final part and list of attached documents.
Important to know! The appeal must include confirmation of payment of the court fee (receipt), evidence of the authority of the signatory of the appeal (if it is not a party to the dispute), copies of the materials that will be subject to analysis. To get more information, we suggest ordering a consultation with our civil lawyer.
When can a civil court refuse to open appeal proceedings?
Current national legislation provides for three scenarios under which a complaint may not be considered. First, when it may be left without action, second, returned, third, receiving a refusal to open civil proceedings. Let us consider each of the cases separately:
- leaving the complaint without action. This happens when significant shortcomings are identified in the complaint, for the correction of which the court may give up to 10 days; when the deadline for an appeal has been missed and a motion for its renewal has not been filed;
- return of the complaint. The court does not consider the document at all if the authority of the signatory, lawyer is not properly confirmed, or the person tries to separately appeal the decision that cannot be appealed in this way under the Civil Procedure Code;
- refusal to open appellate proceedings. This is the worst-case scenario that can occur if the person has already appealed this very decision and the court has already closed the proceedings, and a year has passed since the first instance court’s decision was announced (with exceptions for those who were not notified of the court at all).
How will a lawyer help you in civil cases?
Assistance from a lawyer in civil cases is a whole complex of measures that begins long before the court hearing. Civil legislation has many procedural pitfalls, where even a technical error can cost you a victory in the future. The law firm “Prikhodko & Partners” offers to order a lawyer support service, which will consist of:
- strategic planning and risk analysis;
- pre-trial settlement of a civil dispute (if possible);
- formation of an evidentiary base and preparation for the trial in general;
- preparation of an appeal and annexes to it;
- work with specialists in cases of appointment of an expert examination;
- representation of the client’s positions in court;
- further support (in particular in cassation proceedings).
Do you have any questions? We suggest you order a consultation and find out the cost of legal support in an appeal by filling out the form below.
Calculate the cost of services
1 question
Are you the plaintiff in the case?
2 question
Are you a defendant in a civil dispute?
3 question
Are you interested in renewing the deadline for filing an appeal?
You may also need:
call back
during the day
Trial lawyer: support and defense in court
Telegram
Viber
WhatsApp
Facebook
Instagram