Head of family law practice
An attorney with extensive experience specializing in complex family disputes. As Head of Practice, he combines deep legal expertise with a personalized approach to every client. He ensures strategic protection of family interests and delivers impeccable results in the most challenging cases.
Contesting the gift contract
Donation is one of the most common civil law agreements, regulated by the Civil Code of Ukraine. At first glance, concluding a donation agreement looks simple: one party transfers property to the other free of charge.
However, practice shows that such disinterestedness can hide manipulation, violation of rights, abuse of trust, and sometimes outright pressure.
In such situations, there is a need to legally challenge the agreement.
What is a gift agreement according to the legislation of Ukraine?
According to the provisions of the Civil Code, a donation agreement is a transaction under which one party (the donor) transfers property or a property right to another party (the donee) free of charge.
The absence of any obligations on the part of the donee is a key feature of a donation, which distinguishes it from a purchase and sale or exchange.
In most cases, the objects of donation are:
- apartments and residential buildings;
- land plots;
- vehicles;
- valuables, jewels;
- money.
The conclusion of a gift agreement is regulated by the norms of Chapter 55 of the Civil Code of Ukraine (Articles 717–730). At the same time, there are strict requirements for the form and procedure for concluding the agreement, especially when it comes to real estate.
In what cases can a gift agreement be appealed?
Despite the fact that a donation is a voluntary act, the legislation allows it to be challenged in certain situations.
The main grounds for appeal are:
- Failure to comply with the legal form of the contract
The donation of real estate is subject to mandatory notarial certification and state registration. If these requirements are violated, the transaction has no legal force.
For example, an oral agreement or a simple written contract without a notary regarding the transfer of an apartment is not recognized as valid.
- Lack of true will on the part of the donor
The conclusion of a contract must be the result of a conscious decision of the person. If a person was under the influence of illness, alcohol, medication or other external influence, his will is considered distorted.
There may also be grounds for declaring the transaction invalid in the case of psychological or physical pressure.
- Deception or misrepresentation
If the donor was intentionally misled regarding the content of the contract, the purpose of the transfer of property, or other essential conditions, this is grounds for declaring the transaction invalid in accordance with Article 230 of the Civil Code.
- Presence of mental or age limitations
Persons who are recognized as incompetent or with limited legal capacity do not have the right to independently conclude such transactions. If the contract is concluded without the participation of a legal representative or permission of the guardianship authority, it may be declared invalid.
- The hidden purpose of the contract
Donations are sometimes used to circumvent mandatory taxes, obligations, or court judgments.
If it is determined that the contract had a purpose other than that officially stated—for example, to conceal the sale or avoid collection—it is considered fictitious.
- Violation of third party rights
If the donation violates the rights of co-owners, spouses, heirs, or other persons, they have the right to demand the cancellation of the contract through the court.
Who has the right to challenge a donation agreement?
According to civil law, the following may apply to the court to declare a contract invalid:
- Giver — during life, in case of change of circumstances or detection of fraud.
- Heirs of the donor — after his death, if they have evidence of violations or pressure.
- Guardians, caretakers — in the event of a person being recognized as incapacitated or with limited legal capacity.
- Third parties — for example, if the property was transferred in violation of the right of joint ownership or inheritance.
Deadlines for appeal
The right to appeal to the court is limited by the limitation period, which is three years from the moment when the person learned or could have learned about the violation of his rights.
In the case of invalidity of the contract due to pressure or fraud, the calculation of the period begins from the date of discovery of the relevant facts, and not from the date of signing.
In exceptional cases (for example, due to serious illness or other valid reasons), the deadline may be extended if an appropriate request is submitted and justification is provided.
How does the appeal procedure work?
To initiate the recognition of a gift agreement as invalid, you must go through several stages:
- Preparation of the evidence base
The claimant must provide convincing documents that confirm his legal position:
- certificates from medical institutions;
- testimonies of relatives or third parties;
- copies of contracts;
- expert opinions;
- correspondence or audio recordings (subject to compliance with evidentiary requirements).
- Drafting a claim
The statement of claim is drawn up in writing in accordance with the requirements of the Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine (Articles 175–177 of the Civil Procedure Code of Ukraine).
It should contain:
- a brief summary of the circumstances;
- justification of requirements;
- references to legal norms;
- list of evidence.
- Filing a lawsuit in court
The application is filed with the local court at the defendant’s place of residence or at the location of the property (if it is real estate). It is also important to pay the court fee and submit all copies of documents in the proper form.
- Court proceedings
During the hearing of the case, the court may order expert examinations (psychiatric, handwriting analysis, etc.), hear witnesses, and examine all the evidence provided. The court evaluates each fact separately and also checks whether the rights of one of the parties have been violated.
- Court decision
If grounds for invalidity are established, the court declares the contract invalid in whole or in part. The consequence is the return of the property or compensation.
Consequences of declaring a gift agreement invalid
If a transaction is declared invalid, the parties are returned to the state in which they were before its conclusion (restitution).
This means:
- the property is returned to the donor;
- The donee is obliged to return the received or compensate for its cost.
If the return of the property is not possible (for example, it has been sold or destroyed), compensation for damages or other methods of protection are allowed.
What is the difference between cancellation of a contract and its invalidity?
Two concepts should be distinguished:
- Invalidity — is the legal status of a contract concluded in violation of the law. It can be null and void (automatically) or recognized by a court.
- Abolition — this is the donor’s initiative to cancel the contract due to ingratitude or other actions of the donee (Article 727 of the Civil Code).
In both cases, the consequence is the termination of the donee’s rights to the property received, but the mechanisms for implementation are different.
Challenging a donation agreement is a real tool for protecting citizens’ rights in cases of abuse of trust, fraud, or violation of the law. It is important to remember: not every agreement can be canceled based solely on moral considerations. Clear legal grounds supported by evidence are needed.
If you believe that your interests have been violated, or have doubts about the validity of the transaction, do not delay consulting with the lawyers of the Law Firm “Prikhodko and Partners”.
In many cases, timely appeal to specialists allows you to avoid litigation or prepare for it as effectively as possible.
Calculate the cost of services
1 question
Have other lawyers handled your case?
2 question
Are you in Kyiv or Kyiv region?
3 question
Do you need legal help urgently?
You may also need:
Registration of care on a non-professional basis
Read moreAppeal of inheritance contract
Read moreDivision of foreign assets upon divorce
Read moreAccompaniment of a lawyer in the children’s service
Read moreAPOSTILLE AND LEGALIZATION OF DOCUMENTS IN UKRAINE
Read moreObtaining a MSEC certificate of disability
Read moreConfirmation of independent maintenance of the child
Read moreEstablishment of guardianship over an incapacitated person
Read moreLegal assistance in establishing disability
Read moreEstablishing custody of the child
Read moreRegistration of a child born through reproductive medicine
Read moreREGISTRATION OF PERMISSION FOR THE CHILD TO GO ABROAD FROM ONE OF THE PARENTS
Read morecall back
during the day
Compensation for moral, material damage
Protection of honour, dignity, and business reputationContract Development for Business and Legal Entities
Licensing of business activities
Compensation for moral, material damage
Legal services in the field of cryptocurrency and blockchain
REGISTRATION OF COMPANIES AND OPENING OF BANK ACCOUNTS
Sale and purchase of ready-made firms
Grants and attracting investment
Business registration and support in Great Britain
Business registration and support in Switzerland
Business registration and support in the EU
Business Registration and Support in the Gulf Countries (GCC)
Business registration and support in Turkey
Business registration and support in USA
Lawyer for administrative cases
Legal services for medical businesses and doctors
Protection of honour, dignity, and business reputation
Real estate transaction support
Escort of the tender participant
Trial lawyer: support and defense in court
European Court of Human Rights (ECHR)

