Civil action for compensation for material damage

Compensation for material damage is an important legal mechanism that allows victims to receive reimbursement for incurred losses. This can include compensation for both damaged property and expenses related to restoration or medical treatment. In this article, we will review the key aspects of filing a claim for material damage compensation, present court case examples, and offer tips on drafting a claim.

What is Material Damage Compensation?

Material damage refers to losses suffered by an individual due to the unlawful actions of another person. It may include:

• Direct damages: the actual costs of restoring damaged property or health. For example, the cost of repairing a vehicle damaged in an accident.
• Lost profits: income a person could have earned if the damage had not occurred. For example, lost profit because the vehicle could not be used during repairs. Ukrainian legislation requires full compensation for material damage, including both direct losses and potential lost profits.

This is regulated by Article 22 of the Civil Code of Ukraine, which outlines the compensation mechanism in cases of unlawful actions causing harm.

How to File a Claim for Material Damage Compensation?

The process of filing a claim for material damage compensation includes several key steps:

1. Gathering evidence: to increase the chances of a successful claim, it is crucial to collect all necessary evidence confirming the damage and its extent. This evidence may include:
   • Property damage assessment reports;
   • Receipts for repair work or medical expenses;
   • Photos or videos documenting the damage;
   • Witness statements or expert opinions.
   The collected evidence will help the court make a justified decision regarding the compensation amount.
2. Preparing a claim
   A claim for material damage compensation should be drafted in accordance with Ukrainian law and include:
   • The names and contact details of the plaintiff and defendant;
   • A description of the circumstances under which the damage occurred;
   • Documents confirming the amount of material damage;
   • The plaintiff's demands for compensation.
   The proper structure and content of the claim are crucial for the successful consideration of the case in court.

Example of Court Practice

One example of court practice is case No75031032, which was considered by a Ukrainian court. In this case, a person’s rights were violated as a result of a road accident. The court found the defendant liable for causing material damage, as their actions led to the plaintiff's vehicle being damaged. As a result, the court ordered the defendant to pay compensation based on the assessed damage, which included both the repair of the vehicle and expenses for additional services related to property restoration.

What Does a Material Damage Compensation Claim Include?
A claim for material damage compensation is an official document in which the plaintiff outlines all the circumstances under which the damages were incurred and their demands for compensation. It should include:

• Description of the damage: when and how the damages occurred;
  Documents proving the damages: receipts, repair bills, recovery expenses;
• The plaintiff’s demands: a specific sum that they require as compensation.

The claim should also indicate how the damage affected the plaintiff's property or financial situation. Keep in mind that any inaccuracy in wording or lack of evidence can result in delays or even the rejection of the claim.

Material Damage Compensation in Criminal Cases

Material damage can be compensated not only within civil proceedings but also in criminal cases, where the victim can file a civil claim within the criminal proceedings. In such cases, the civil claim becomes part of the criminal process, and the court addresses the issue of material damage compensation while delivering the verdict on the offender. This is advantageous for plaintiffs as it allows them to obtain compensation without having to file a separate claim in civil court.

Criminal proceedings concerning material damage compensation provide the victim with an opportunity to avoid lengthy trials in civil courts. For example, in cases of theft or fraud, material damage can be recovered based on a court verdict that establishes the offender's guilt.

Determining the Compensation Amount

The court determines the compensation amount based on the evidence provided. The plaintiff must prove not only the fact of the damage but also its extent. This may include:
• Estimates of repair costs;
• Expert assessments of the condition of damaged property;
• Documents proving expenses for treatment or other necessary services.

The court may also take into account lost profits — the loss of income or opportunities that arose due to the inability to use property or other resources during the recovery process. For example, in the case of vehicle damage, the court may consider lost profit the owner could have earned if the vehicle was used for commercial transportation.

Why Act Now?

Every minute you delay in addressing the issue of material damage compensation benefits the guilty party. The longer time passes, the harder it becomes to gather necessary evidence, and your chances of success diminish. The psychological pressure and stress from the loss can only increase if no action is taken promptly.

Your situation may become more complicated while you hesitate. A lack of decisive action can lead to a loss of confidence in justice and risks leaving you without proper compensation. Don't let the guilty take advantage of your passivity. Every day of delay is a lost opportunity for success in your case.

Imagine that today you take the first step and contact professional lawyers. We guarantee that you will not be left alone with your problems. Our experience and knowledge will help you navigate this complex process with confidence. Only professionals can prepare a convincing claim and ensure your protection in court.

Your right to compensation can be lost forever if you do not act immediately. Contact us now, as every minute of delay works against you!

Ready to take action?

Great. Readiness is half the battle. The rest is up to us.

1. Fill out the Form below
2. Receive a Personalized Consultation
3. Find out the Cost of our Services