Detention of a person without a decision of an investigating judge – Article 208 of the Criminal Procedure Code

Today, detention of a person without a court decision remains a high-risk area for human rights violations. Without an investigating judge’s order, a person may be held for up to 72 hours, and this period cannot exceed the limit established by law. If there are no clear grounds предусмотрені Article 208 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine, such detention is unlawful from the moment of actual restriction of liberty.

Arbitrary restriction of liberty under the pretext of “clarifying circumstances” in the absence of legal grounds is a gross violation of the right to personal inviolability and creates grounds for challenging such actions. Criminal defense lawyers of the law firm Prikhodko and Partners promptly respond to such cases, document violations, and build a defense strategy from the very first hours.

Article 208 of the Criminal Procedure Code of Ukraine

The regime of lawful restriction of liberty without prior judicial control is based on procedural legislation provisions that define an exhaustive list of grounds for such actions. Such detention is allowed only in cases предусмотрених by law and is carried out by authorized entities without prior court authorization. These are situations where a person’s involvement in a criminal offense is очевидною at the moment of actual detention.

In practice, there are three scenarios:

1. the person is caught in the act of committing a crime or attempting to commit one;
2. immediately after the incident, witnesses or victims directly identify the person;
3. there are clear traces of the crime — on the body, clothing, or at the scene.

The key criterion in this context is “urgency.” If the circumstances are not obvious and require additional fact-finding, detention without a court order already becomes questionable in terms of legality.

When is a person considered detained?

In practice, the critical factor is not the paperwork but the actual situation. A person is considered detained from the moment they lose the ability to freely leave the place. For example:

• use of handcuffs;
• blocking the ability to leave the location;
• physical restraint by police officers.

From this moment, the detention period begins to run. Any manipulation with the recording of time is a gross violation of human rights.

What is the maximum period of detention without an investigating judge’s order?

The maximum period of holding a person in custody without an investigating judge’s order is 72 hours from the moment of actual detention. According to the CPC, this period is preclusive (final) and is calculated from the moment of actual detention.

This period is absolute and does not allow for broad interpretation or “technical” adjustments by law enforcement authorities. The countdown starts not from the drafting of the protocol, but from the actual restriction of freedom of movement — for example, when handcuffs are applied or when a person is prevented from leaving the scene.

Within these 72 hours, the authorized authorities must:

• release the person if there are no grounds for further detention;
• bring them before a court to consider the issue of a preventive measure.

Any exceeding of this period automatically creates grounds for declaring such actions unlawful. At the same time, this may become a key argument for the defense to:

• challenge the actions of law enforcement officers;
• declare evidence inadmissible;
• change or cancel the preventive measure.

Lawyers of “Prikhodko and Partners” in such situations immediately check the timeline of detention, the correctness of documentation, and the existence of procedural decisions in order to use every violation in the client’s interests.

Comparison table — how long can a person be detained?

What procedural status does a person detained under Article 208 CPC of Ukraine acquire?

The status of a suspect arises at the moment of restriction of liberty, even if the formal written notice of suspicion has not yet been served. This means the person acquires a number of procedural rights:

• the right to a lawyer;
• the right not to testify against oneself;
• the right to know the essence of the suspicion;
• the right to medical assistance.

Ignoring these rights is a direct violation of the CPC of Ukraine.

Failure to comply with the deadlines for serving a notice of suspicion nullifies the legality of further detention and requires the immediate release of the person.

Detention without a court order is allowed only under clearly defined legal conditions and cannot be applied arbitrarily. In practice, however, law enforcement officers often exceed these powers, which creates grounds for appealing and declaring such actions unlawful.

If you have faced detention or there is a risk of it — you must act immediately. Every hour matters.

Lawyers of the law firm “Prikhodko and Partners” provide full legal support in criminal proceedings: from analyzing the legality of detention to building a strong defense strategy in court.

Do not waste time — seek legal advice now. Fill out the form below to calculate the cost for your case.