Attorney
Lawyer, specializing in defense in criminal proceedings regarding serious and especially serious crimes - against life and health, sexual integrity, war crimes with aggravating circumstances, as well as in cases related to violations in the field of taxation
Desertion: legal aspects and responsibility
Table of Contents:
Desertion is one of the most serious military offenses, which directly affects the defense capability of the state and the combat readiness of military units. In Ukraine, responsibility for desertion is defined by Article 408 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine (CCU). Let us consider the legal nature of this crime, the conditions for bringing it to justice, the features of the investigation and trial.
According to Article 408 of the CCU, desertion is the voluntary abandonment by a serviceman of a military unit or place of service in order to evade military service, as well as failure to report for duty for the same purpose. Desertion differs from other military offenses in its purposefulness - the serviceman does not simply violate the rules, but does so deliberately, with the intention of avoiding military duty.
The object of this crime is the established procedure for military service, which ensures the coordinated work of the Armed Forces of Ukraine and other military formations.
The subject of the crime is a military serviceman serving in the Armed Forces of Ukraine or other military formations. This can be both conscripts and contract soldiers. The peculiarity is that the subjects of desertion cannot be civilians.
The motives for desertion can be different:
- Fear of combat. A serviceman leaves the service, not wanting to risk his life.
- Dissatisfaction with the conditions of service. Unsatisfactory living conditions, conflicts with the command or fellow soldiers can push him to desertion.
- Political or ideological reasons. A serviceman may disagree with the policy of the command or the country.
- Personal reasons. The need to be with his family, the desire to avoid responsibility for other offenses, etc.
The main goal of desertion is to evade military duties.
Article 408 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine establishes the following types of punishment for desertion:
- Part 1. For wilful abandonment of a unit or failure to report for service with the aim of evading service, imprisonment for a term of two to five years is provided.
- Part 2. If desertion is committed with weapons or by prior conspiracy by a group of persons, the punishment is imprisonment for a term of five to ten years.
- Part 3. Desertion in conditions of martial law or hostilities is punishable by imprisonment for a term of five to twelve years.
In conditions of martial law or armed conflict, desertion becomes particularly dangerous to society. In such situations, servicemen are a key link in ensuring the country's defense capability, and their absence can lead to serious consequences for the unit or the general military situation.
The harsher punishment during martial law is justified by the need to maintain discipline in the troops. Crimes committed during war are considered more serious because they directly affect national security.
The investigation of desertion is carried out by specialized units of the military prosecutor's office. The main stages are:
- Initiation of criminal proceedings. This occurs after the fact of the absence of a serviceman is recorded.
- Search for the person. If the serviceman does not return voluntarily, he is declared wanted.
- Interrogation of witnesses. Commanders and fellow servicemen give evidence about the behavior of the deserter before the disappearance.
- Establishing motives. It is determined whether the serviceman had good reasons for his absence.
A serviceman accused of desertion has the right to defense. The lawyer performs the following functions:
- Analyzes the evidence presented by the prosecution.
- Protects the client from unfounded accusations.
- Provides legal assistance during interrogations, investigative actions and court proceedings.
- Helps prove mitigating circumstances (for example, psychological state, duress).
Mitigating circumstances:
- Voluntary return. If a person returned to the unit and announced their decision on their own, this may reduce the severity of the punishment.
- The presence of good reasons. For example, illness, threat to life or health from commanders or fellow soldiers.
- Sincere remorse.
Aggravating circumstances:
- Desertion with weapons.
- Committing a crime by prior conspiracy by a group of persons.
- Desertion in combat conditions.
Preventing desertion includes:
- Maintaining proper service conditions. Providing military personnel with everything necessary to perform their duties.
- Psychological support. Working with military personnel to reduce stress.
- Strengthening military discipline.
Desertion is a serious crime that undermines the combat capability of military units and threatens the security of the state. At the same time, it is important to ensure that such cases are dealt with fairly, taking into account all the circumstances that may have influenced the behavior of the serviceman. Effective law enforcement and crime prevention are key elements in the fight against desertion.
Calculate the price of assistance:
1 question
Have other lawyers handled your case?
2 question
Are you in Kyiv or Kyiv region?
3 question
Do you need legal assistance urgently?
What punishment can be applied for desertion?
The punishment for desertion is determined by the circumstances of the act. It can range from imprisonment for several years to more severe sanctions if the desertion occurred during war, with the participation of weapons or as part of hostilities. The court evaluates all factors, including the presence of aggravating or mitigating circumstances. The decision on punishment is always individual and depends on the specific case.
Can a soldier be exempted from liability if he voluntarily returns?
The legislation provides for the possibility of mitigating the punishment in case of voluntary return to the unit or reporting to the commander. However, this does not guarantee complete exemption from liability, since the court takes into account other circumstances of the case. Voluntary reporting can be regarded as a sign of remorse and have a positive impact on the sentence.
What circumstances can be mitigating for desertion?
Mitigating factors may include a severe psychological condition, a threat to life or health, duress, illness, or other force majeure circumstances. The court takes into account whether the military officer’s actions were voluntary or carried out under external pressure. The defendant’s behavior after the offense is also important.
Is there a statute of limitations for prosecution for desertion?
Yes, there are statutes of limitations for desertion under criminal law. However, they may vary depending on the gravity of the offense and the circumstances under which the crime was committed. The statutes may be extended in the event of war or particularly grave circumstances.
Can desertion charges be appealed?
The charge of desertion can be challenged through the appellate or cassation courts. The defense can also prove lack of intent, duress, or other mitigating circumstances. A lawyer helps to formulate a legal position and prepare relevant evidence.
What evidence is commonly used in desertion cases?
Evidence includes duty logs, statements from colleagues, CCTV footage, correspondence and reports of absence without valid reason. Medical certificates and characteristics may also be used to support mitigating circumstances.
How can a lawyer help in a desertion case?
A lawyer protects the rights of a military person during the investigation and trial. He collects evidence that may mitigate the punishment, including characteristics and medical certificates. A lawyer challenges procedural violations and prepares a well-founded legal position for the court. All this increases the chances of a fair verdict or mitigation of the punishment.
How does desertion differ from leaving a unit without permission?
Desertion is the temporary absence of a serviceman without the permission of the command, when there is no intention to evade service.
Desertion implies a conscious and long-term intention not to return to the military unit at all.
Thus, the key difference is the presence of the intention to completely avoid military service.
Is fleeing a combat zone considered desertion?
Thus, if a serviceman leaves a combat position or military unit without an order from the commander and has no intention of returning, this may be qualified as desertion.
Particularly strict liability arises if this occurred under martial law or during hostilities.
Does the fact that a soldier was under threat to his life or pressure affect the punishment?
Yes, such circumstances can be mitigating or exclude the crime if it is proven that the actions were forced. For example, if a person acted under duress, under the threat of death, or due to a serious mental condition, this is taken into account by the court.
What to do if a soldier disappeared not intentionally, but due to loss of communication or capture?
The importance of the case lies in confirming the stability of property rights and the inviolability of legally executed land agreements, which is important for all judicial practice in the field of real estate.
Is attempted desertion punishable if the person was detained before escaping?
Yes, even an attempted desertion is a criminal act. However, the punishment may be lower than for completed desertion if the person did not have time to fully realize the intention.
Can a soldier avoid criminal liability if, after escaping, he voluntarily appears before the military prosecutor's office?
Yes, voluntary appearance with a confession may be grounds for mitigation of punishment or release from liability. This is considered by the court, taking into account the circumstances, the period of absence, and the sincerity of remorse.
What are the consequences for a military member's family if he is recognized as a deserter?
There are no actual sanctions against the family, but social guarantees (payments, assistance) may be suspended. The family may also suffer reputational impact if the case becomes public.
Does desertion affect a person's future employment or reputation?
Yes, a conviction for desertion is a serious obstacle to work in government agencies, law enforcement agencies, and the Armed Forces of Ukraine. Even after the conviction is expunged, such information may be taken into account during an integrity or security check.
call back
during the day
Telegram
Viber
WhatsApp
Facebook
Instagram